Home Equity Loans - Beware of Appraisal Fraud


A new report by the independent Demos group has revealed what may not be a surprise to many people - corruption is rampant in the home appraisal industry. The bust in the dot-com market of some five years ago has left would-be lenders with a surplus of cash to lend. This has led to a huge boom in both mortgage and home equity loan lending. That's not a bad thing; a record 69% of Americans now own their own homes. Owning a home is easier than ever; in 2004 the average down payment was a record low of only three percent.

So if everyone is buying a home, and loans are easier to obtain than ever, what is the problem? The problem is that nearly 55% of the appraisers polled in the survey said that they had been pressured by lenders to deliver appraisals that met a "target" value. The appraisers said that failure to meet the "target" value resulted in either their not being paid, or not being hired again. Since most appraisers want to keep working, they have had a tendency to meet the target value, even if it means that they have overestimated the value of the property. This drives prices artificially higher and leaves many homeowners with mortgages that may be worth more than the homes they were meant to finance. This problem becomes acute should the owner need to sell the home, only to discover that it isn't worth as much as he or she owes on it.

The worst-case scenario to result from this would be a burst in the current real estate "bubble" and a nationwide collapse in home values, leading to massive foreclosures. This probably will not happen, but there are several things prospective borrowers can do to avoid being caught in the appraisal trap:

  • *Become educated about the appraisal and lending process. The more informed you are, the less likely you are to be caught in a scam.

  • *Be aware that refinancing your home isn't a cure to all problems. It may seem appealing to use the equity in your home for such uses as debt consolidation but if the result of that is that you owe more on your home than it is worth, you probably haven't gained anything.

  • *Be active in the appraisal process. Talk to the appraiser, and ask to see the finished appraisal, along with the data used to create it. Appraisals are based in part on the sales of similar properties in your area. Check them out yourself and compare the home you saw with the stated appraisal value.

  • *Be bold. Ask your lender if they pressure their appraisers to provide inflated values. You might not get an honest answer, but pay attention to how they respond. You might be able to determine if they are lying.

    • Ultimately, if you take out a home equity loan or a mortgage for more than your home is worth, you are the one that suffers. That can be easily avoided if you simply pay more attention to the process and educate yourself about the possible pitfalls. The last thing you want to lose is your home.

    ©Copyright 2005 by Retro Marketing. Charles Essmeier is the owner of Retro Marketing, a firm devoted to informational Websites, including http://www.End-Your-Debt.com/ and http://www.HomeEquityHelp.net/

    MORE RESOURCES:
    RELATED ARTICLES
    Fixtures
    Fixtures, related to real estate, are items that were originally personal property but are now attached to the property itself. This becomes the toughest issue when tenants attach fixtures to a property.
    Buying A Holiday Home in Rural Ireland
    Ireland has recently witnessed an upsurge in the number of investors buying holiday homes in some of the country's most scenic areas. With stars like Jeremy Irons and Daniel Day-Lewis popping up in the quaint villages of West Cork, prices in many of these areas are at a premium.
    Inspecting Your New Home - 17 Areas You Must Inspect Before Taking Possession
    Congratulations! You've made your decision; you've chosen your new home and your builder. So what needs to happen next? Once you have a firm contract and you have selected the features that will go into your new home, it is time for the builder to turn your dream into reality.
    Is It Wise to Take My Home Off the Market for the Holidays?
    Let's say you've had your home on the market for many months without a sale. The holidays are drawing near.
    Selling Property - Valuing Your Property
    Selling property privately has many advantages over using an estate agent. However estate agents can provide useful local information not available from the internet.
    Tax Deferred Exchanges of Investment and Business Real Estate
    The Primary Residence taxation, the Residential Replacement Rollover, Sec. 1034 exception is gone.
    Water, Water Everywhere on the Waterfront
    Waterfront living is among the most desirable of locations in our area (Florida). The views and vistas are fantastic, not to mention the ability to walk out one's door to drop a line to fish or untie a line to enjoy boating.
    5 Things to Look for in a Property Appraiser
    Homeowners who are seeking a property appraiser often ask "How should I choose which real estate appraiser to use?" When selecting a property appraiser, keep the following in mind:Always make sure a property appraiser is licensed or certified by the state to perform real estate appraisals. While state licensing and/or certification isn't always an indication of quality, it ensures that an individual is has met certain standards and been authorized to perform property appraisals.
    Real Estate Investing - Free Vacations While Searching for Real Estate Acquisitions
    Real estate investing professionals look for all possible tax deductions because of the generous profits derived from real estate investing.For example, real estate investors are concerned whether the sale of their real estate is subject to capital gains taxation or qualifies as ordinary income.
    Regarding Real Estate On Leased Land
    1.Why are there so many properties on leased land?There are several situations here.
    Why Commercial Real Estate is the Hottest Retirement Asset
    For small business owners, commercial real estate investment is the hottest new retirement asset. If your mind has already jumped to "REITs" - or shares in Real Estate Investment Trusts - think again.
    Selling Houses: Design Psychology Works!
    I've taught the concepts of Design Psychology for many years, and I know how much it can empower a person, and allow them to create a fabulous home that sustains their emotions. Since it's based on science, I know that Design Psychology is effective at turning plain spaces into happy places.
    Seller Objections To Lease Purchase
    A large percentage of the mail we receive are from people that complain that sellers don't want to do a lease purchase, they just want to sell their house. Or sellers come up with too many objections.
    What is Tax-Deferred Exchange?
    Under Section 1031 of the Internal Revenue Code, owners of real estate held for investment or use in a trade or business can swap their property tax-free for "like-kind" real estate. Exchanges are made for people wanting to stay invested in real estate, increase their leverage and to avoid paying hefty taxes upon the sale of property.
    Much Ado About Mansionization?
    Is there a perpetual shadow hovering over your house? Do you feel as though you live in a Batman movie? You may be the victim of a neighboring McMansion or a new development trend called mansionization, the housing industry's equivalent to bigger portions and fast food.These mansionizers-who are frequently "spec" builders--buy small or dilapidated homes, raze them and erect massive structures, often resembling sterile apartment buildings.
    Buying To Let Top Ten Tips
    Buying to let is considered a serious investment and should not be conducted without some equally serious research. Our top ten tips will get you on the right path to finding out all you need to know to become a seriously successful landlord.
    Secrets of Making Money from Real Estate - Part 1
    There are three investment vehicles which can make you rich. Stocks, businesses, and real estate.
    Selling Your Own Home - Pet Issues
    If you are selling you own home, you need to consider the effect of pets. People who are working with a real estate broker are sure to get coached about the potential negative effect of pets.
    Is Second Home Ownership In Your Future?
    According to the National Association of REALTORS® (NAR), a record 2.82 million second homes were sold in 2004.
    Where Does Your Real Estate Commission Fee Go - Why is The Commission so HIGH?
    Many who have bought and sold properties through Realtors numerous times; even many real estate agents themselves, don't know where the commission money goes. After all, when a property sells for hundreds of thousands of dollars and the commission is tens of thousands of dollars, it seems like there is a terrific amount of money charged as commission -- and there is.